Two years after its introduction the European Commission’s lobby register has failed to bring lobbying into the open, the Alliance for Lobbying Transparency and Ethics Regulation in the EU (ALTER-EU) said today. The group used the anniversary of the register to call on the Commission to take urgent steps towards a mandatory, joint register for the European Commission and European Parliament with improved transparency standards.
While the European Commission continues to spin the register as a success, the reality is quite different. New analysis by ALTER-EU shows that only a minority of Brussels lobbyists are registered.
Only 1068 organisations with a Brussels office are registered. This figure compares to the European Parliament’s estimate of 2,600 lobby groups with offices in Brussels in 2000, and suggests *well under half of Brussels-based lobby organisations and firms have signed up after two years. [1]
Key sectors like lobbying consultancies and corporate EU affairs offices are massively under-represented. ALTER-EU has found out that of a group of 328 consultancies identified as providing EU lobbying services, 163 are listed on the Commission’s register (50 per cent).[2] A report by Friends of the Earth Europe showed that 20 of the largest 50 EU companies (40 per cent) are not signed up to the register.[3]
Law firms providing lobbying services and think tanks also continue to boycott the transparency register, further undermining its credibility.
“When two years after the launch of the register only a minority of Brussels lobbyists are registered, it is clear that the voluntary approach has failed,” says Olivier Hoedeman from Corporate Europe Observatory. “The European Commission must now make a commitment to introduce a mandatory lobby transparency system that enables European citizens to see who is influencing EU decision-making, on which issues, on whose behalf and with what budgets.”
As part of its 10-point action plan for transparency and ethics reforms [4] ALTER-EU suggests a two-step approach to secure a high-quality lobby transparency system :
1) a mandatory register covering all EU institutions to be achieved by the end of this Commission term ;
2) in the short term, the Commission and Parliament must act with determination to make registration a de facto obligation for all actors involved in EU lobbying (including law firms and think tanks) and to improve the reliability of the information disclosed.
ALTER-EU believes significant progress can be achieved with a new joint transparency register currently being negotiated between the Commission and Parliament.[5] A far larger share of Brussels lobbyists would be forced to provide information if registration is made a condition for lobbyists holding access passes to the Parliament. The current negotiations are also a crucial opportunity to fix the flaws in the Commission’s register and introduce more detailed financial transparency requirements, removing the exemptions for large lobby consultancies which only provide very limited information.
“It is high time to close the loopholes and tighten the weak financial disclosure requirements which allow lobby groups to disguise the size of their lobbying effort and make it impossible to determine who the biggest spenders really are and which policies they are trying to influence,” said Natacha Cingotti from Friends of the Earth Europe.
For more information, please contact :
Olivier Hoedeman, Corporate Europe Observatory (EN, NL) Tel : +32 4 7448 6545 +32 4 7448 6545 olivier@corporateeurope.org
Natacha Cingotti, transparency campaigner for Friends of the Earth Europe (EN, FR) Tel : +32 2 893 10 23 natacha.cingotti@foeeurope.org
Notes to the Editor :
[1] Based on a review by ALTER-EU as of 22 June 2010. Details are available upon request.
[2] http://www.alter-eu.org/sites/default/files/documents/eu-lobby-firms-registration-2010-03-22.pdf
The 50% figure comes from an update of this review (22 June 2010), available on request from Corporate Europe Observatory. On 22 June 2010, non registered consultancies included Arcturus Group, Brunswick Group, FIPRA, ICODA and Sarah Biontino Consultants.
[3] http://www.foeeurope.org/corporates/pdf/Lobbying_in_Brussels_April2010.pdf
The report was published in April 2010. Important companies missing from the register include Royal Bank of Scotland, Deutsche Bank, Nestlé.
[4] The action plan is part of the ALTER-EU’s new book, “Bursting the Brussels Bubble – The Battle to expose corporate lobbying at the heart of the EU” on http://www.alter-eu.org/book/bursting-the-brussels-bubble
[5] The joint EP-EC High Level Working Party resumed its talks on a joint lobby register on 6 May 2010. The HLWP is composed of Commissioner Maroš Šefčovič and MEPs Carlo Casini, Isabelle Durant, Jo Leinen and Diana Wallis.